Best Scotches for Bourbon Drinkers in 2024
It’s time to retire the notion that fans of bourbon can’t appreciate Scotch whisky. Sure, some staunchly refuse to broaden their horizons, but as the urban philosopher Jadakiss once noted, “Options [are] a beautiful thing.” Knowing what you like is valuable, but you might be missing out on the joys of an open mind. If you’re a bourbon fan curious about Scotch, this guide is for you.
Exploring the Familiar and the New
Some Bourbon fans might want to explore Scotch but don’t know where to start. Maybe you’re looking for a Scotch that closely resembles your favorite bourbon flavors. Or perhaps you’re curious about the various offerings of Scotch but unsure what to expect. No matter where you fall on the Scotch spectrum, this list has got you covered.
Scotches with a Bourbon-like Flavor Profile
- The Balvenie DoubleWood Aged 12 Years: This Scotch offers approachable flavors similar to what bourbon drinkers enjoy. Notes of honey and butterscotch make it a great crossover whisky.
- The Dalmore 12: With flavors of brandied cherries and honey, this elegant Scotch deserves a spot in any bourbon lover’s cabinet.
- Bunnahabhain 12-Year Whisky: Double matured in ex-bourbon and sherry casks, this whisky showcases a balance and depth of flavors that align well with bourbon drinkers’ palates.
- Lagavulin 16: While peat-forward, its bold flavors will appeal to those who enjoy strong bourbon flavors.
Distinctively Different Yet Delightful
- Glenfiddich 14: This Scotch embraces American oak casks used in bourbon, making it familiar yet intriguing for bourbon fans.
- Compass Box Hedonism: Known for its annual limited release, this blended grain whisky offers a complex blend of flavors that will impress bourbon lovers.
- Bruichladdich 18: This unpeated Islay Scotch offers a unique mix of sweetness and smokiness that bourbon drinkers will find fascinating.
- Aberlour A’bunadh: With its high ABV and sherry sweetness, this Scotch is highly recommended for those who enjoy robust bourbon flavors.
Comparative Flavor Profiles
| Scotch | ABV | Average Price | Tasting Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Balvenie DoubleWood Aged 12 Years | 43% | $70 | Honey, butterscotch, subtle smoke |
| The Dalmore 12 | 40% | $80 | Cherries, honey, mulling spices |
| Bunnahabhain 12-Year Whisky | 46.3% | $50 | Cherry, citrus, cocoa, malt |
| Lagavulin 16 | 43% | $88 | Peat, dark chocolate, ginger candy |
| Glenfiddich 14 | 43% | $70 | Vanilla, pear, toasted almonds |
| Compass Box Hedonism | 43% | $140 | Tropical fruit, allspice, vanilla |
| Bruichladdich 18 | 50% | $195 | Honeyed wheat, hazelnut, chocolate |
| Aberlour A’bunadh | 59.6% | $115 | Red raisins, figs, black cherry |
Discovering Your Preference
While some bourbon fans have an aversion to peat — the organic matter lending many Scotches a campfire flavor — preferences can vary. You might find joy in the smoky notes of certain Scotch offerings. This list includes a bit of both smoky and sweeter Scotches, allowing you to discover your own preference along the way.
A Final Toast
Transitioning from bourbon to Scotch can be an exhilarating journey. The best Scotch for bourbon drinkers in 2024 offers a delightful range from familiar flavors to bold new experiences. So, whether you’re looking for something close to home or ready to venture into the unknown, these Scotches provide a fantastic start. Cheers to new adventures and more enjoyable sipping!
